As reported by dzurek 1996, both countries agreed to abide by a code of. This essay argues that taking a constructivist approach through discourse analysis as described by lene hansen 1 will highlight essential and previously neglected dynamics of the dispute. His solutions to the spratly islands dispute all assume that china will be able to claim eezs and territorial waters around mischief reef and its manmade features. Why philippines has the strongest claim of spratly islands.
The spratly islands cover more than 164,000 square miles from southern vietnam to the philippines. Michael bennett, the peoples republic of china and the use of international law in. According to marcus halls trouble brewing in the south china sea assessment, china entered the dispute in three phases. Maritime briefing v2 n1 nguyen thai hoc foundation. Introduction dn august, 1990, in singapore, premier li peng of the peoples republic of china the prc reaffirmed chinas sovereignty over xisha and nansha islands. Resolving the spratly islands dispute might rename the. Spratly islands is a group of islands, reefs, islets and cays in the south china sea or west philippines sea which is being claimed by asian countries namely the philippines, vietnam, brunei, malaysia, taiwan and peoples republic of china. I strongly believe and stand for the philippines rightful claim to the spratly islands. Spratly dispute, where ownership of the islands is claimed wholly or.
The entire spratly island archipelago, which consists of small reefs, shoals, sandbars, cays, and atolls, covers about 180,000 square kilometers ii with the inclusion of the territorial waters that surround the entire chain. Philippines and china dispute over the spratly islands and. These features, most of which are uninhabitable, are situated in three island chains the spratly, paracel, and pratas islands, the macclesfield. China over the spratly islands in the south china sea its all. Settlement of disputes under the 1982 united nations. There is no generally accepted definition of the spratly islands. China is rapidly transforming numerous reefs of the spratly island group into military installations, part of a strategy to solidify its hold on the south china sea despite competing territorial claims by vietnam, the philippines, malaysia, taiwan and brunei. The south china sea emergence as a major explosive flashpoint in the asia pacific in the second decade of the 21 st century owes its origin to chinas two major acts of aggression against vietnam in the last quarter of the 20 th century, namely the capture of the paracel islands in 1974 and the spratly islands partially in 1988. Abstract the spratly islands of the south china sea are a potential tinder box in the region. The spratlys links the pacific ocean and the indian ocean. Spratly islands are closer to palawan than to vietnam and much more than to china. Though china and taiwan based their claims to the spratlys on the historical records dating back to the sung dynasty a. Chinas claim of sovereignty over spratly and paracel islands. The south china sea is defined by the international hydrographic bureau as the body of water stretching in a southwest to northeast direction, whose southern.
Navy sails warship near disputed islands in south china. For the dispute over sovereignty to islands in the south china sea the. Mar 06, 2018 the spratly islands are a disputed zone, with china, malaysia, taiwan, vietnam, brunei and the philippines all advancing territorial claims, and all except brunei occupying at least some of the maritime features in the area. Cloma then sold his claim to the philippine government and in 1978, president marcos declared the spratly islands, or the kalayaan islands, as philippine. Peaceful settlement of disputes in the south china sea. This book explores the three most prominent island disputes in east asia. Cordner, the spratly island dispute and the law of the sea, 25 ocean dev. Usc wrigley marine science center on catalina island and throughout. Essay about reasons for the spratly island disputes 465 words.
The spratly islands are a disputed zone, with china, malaysia, taiwan, vietnam, brunei and the philippines all advancing territorial claims, and all except brunei occupying at least some of the maritime features in the area. Chinas standpoint with respect to international law and territorial disputes as. We own the the spratly because it lies on our 200 nm border. Autobiography of malcolm x 416 reprint edition 1992. Territorial dispute of the spratly islands in the south china sea. A historical and legal perspective tehkuang chang i. This legalistic approach has helped mitigate chinese claims, but facts on the ground and on the water also matter. In terms of national security, these islands are important due to their location in the south china sea, where many merchant ships pass through to deliver goods, people, and energy products to asianpacific countries. Philippines and china concerning their maritime dispute in the south china sea. The spratly island dispute is about national pride as well as the potential economic resources of the area. South china sea and east asia territorial disputes.
Navy told the japan times on tuesday that it had sailed a warship near the contested spratly islands in the south china sea home to fortified island islands built by china on. The republic of chinas government also announced a sovereignty claim on the spratly islands. Spratly islands military bases revealed spatial source. Spratly island dispute spratly islands dispute the spratly islands of the south china sea are potential sources of different natural resources. Chinese soldiers on the spratly islands, known in china as the nansha islands, in february. Peace and conflict monitor, the management of the spratly. Your indian navy base argument was simply based on incorrect information. The spratly islands in the south china sea are rich in fishing and oil reserves. Essay about reasons for the spratly island disputes 465. Approximately 44 of the 51 small islands and reefs are claimed or occupied by china, the philippines, vietnam, taiwan, malaysia and brunei. It also notes that while asean has tried to manage the dispute multilaterally through dialogue and consultation, it has not yet been successful in playing a mediating role due to a lack of consensus among its member states. May use military to confront china in spratly island. Singapore was one of the 14 states of malaysia from 1963 to 1965.
Hagues south china sea spratly verdict all about real estate. Due to the complexity of the south china sea dispute, negotiations have been lagging since the 2002 declaration on the. Laymon jones, a member of the americanphilippine commission, gives his input on the spratly island dispute between the philippines and china. Maritime boundary in the waters north of the natuna islands between. However, what these features are, exactly, cant be overlooked when examining this issue. Basic law of the sea terminology will be discussed to aid in the description of jurisdictional problems. The artificial islands being built in the south china sea have since been militarized, bringing the dispute to an alarming and threatening place. The spratly islands, in the southern reaches of the south china sea, have become the focus of an unstabilising territorial dispute.
Island disputes and maritime regime building in east asia. These south china sea disputes generally fall into three categories. The spratly islands are seen to have rich fishing grounds and are believed to have guano. The indonesiansponsored dialogue on the issue, which took place in the 1990s, has lost its momentum in the current climate. The whole group is claimed by china, taiwan, and vietnam, and parts are claimed by malaysia and the philippines. After japans withdrawal from the region at the end of world war ii, the roc stationed troops on itu aba island. Resolution of the dispute is likely in only four ways.
As is shown, the spratly islands dispute has been viewed through mostly realist and structural realist lenses and to a lesser extent through liberal ones. The malaysian foreign ministrys statement is clearly worded so that there is no scope for any complaint alleging ambiguity. South china sea and spratly islands were taiwans territory and under taiwanese sovereignty recently, the dispute has escalated to include military and naval occupation of the islands form the various stakeholders. This marked the end of a 144year british rule in singapore which began with the founding of modern singapore by sir. France asserted its claims to the spratly and paracel islands on behalf of its thencolony vietnam. And wiki is not a valid source when it comes to sensitive political issues. They lie on a shallow continental shelf which has an average depth of only 600 feet. May 02, 2018 china quietly installed missile systems on strategic spratly islands in hotly contested south china sea published wed, may 2 2018 4. But see christopher joyner, the spratly islands dispute. Underscored by the prospects of large natural energy reserves, control of strategic. Security implications of conflict in the south china.
Chinese general visits disputed spratly islands in south china sea. An international history of the dispute in the south china sea. This was due, in part, to chinas rising economic stature and the interdependency it, in turn, fostered amongst asian nations. In order to better understand the politics of the south china sea, it is necessary to divide the waters into two zones.
The spratly islands dispute is an ongoing territorial dispute between brunei, china peoples republic of china, malaysia, the philippines, taiwan, and vietnam, concerning ownership of the spratly islands, a group of islands and associated maritime features reefs, banks, cays, etc. Spratly islands dispute news and updates from the economic. Chinese general visits disputed spratly islands in south. Nonfilipino viewpoints regarding philippine occupation of several islands are currently not included in this article. D 960, it was not until 1946 that taiwan took possession of the itu aba islandthe largest spratly island, and 1951 that china claimed the spratlys. Sanya city includes the disputed spratly islands on a cruise route. Spratly islands dispute article about spratly islands. After that, the paper briefly concludes with a prospectus on the issue of south china sea. As a result, roc officials claim that taiwan was the first to occupy part of the spratly chain and was the first to assert.
Chinas claim of sovereignty over spratly and paracel. Philippines and the spratly islands this article discusses the policies, activities and history of the republic of the philippines in the spratly islands from the philippine perspective. Jul 19, 2015 as is shown, the spratly islands dispute has been viewed through mostly realist and structural realist lenses and to a lesser extent through liberal ones. Islands, reefs, banks and shoals in the south china sea, including the paracel islands, the pratas islands, macclesfield bank, scarborough shoal and the spratly islands between the prc, taiwan, and vietnam, and parts of the area also contested by malaysia and the philippines. Reasons why philippines has the strongest claim of spratly islands. Prospects for peace in spratly islands dispute politics essay. Spratly islands is more than a territorial dispute over a collection of reefs and atolls. Five of the seas littoral states or political entities lay conflicting claims to all or part of the island group and have set up military outposts in them as prospects of significant hydrocarbon resources in the sea floor mount. Ho park research fellow in east asian legal studies, harvard law school, cambridge, massachusetts.
Taiwan, which occupies this island, calls it taiping island. Video by truth esguerra interact with philippine news. In the end, the conflict in the spratly islands is not one for the united. The islands are situated at the heart of the south china sea making it a hotbed for china to claim their territory. The first possible recorded human interaction with the spratly islands dates back as far as 3bce and is based on the discovery of coins left by chinese mariners. In order to set forth these problems, it will first be necessary to describe the geography of the spratly islands, their location, physical composition, what exactly is disputed, why, and by whom. Vietnam, malaysia, and brunei also claim the island group in whole or in part. Download pdf 0 mb abstract the spratly islands dispute is a regional maritime territorial sovereignty dispute which involves six countries in the south china sea china, taiwan, vietnam, philippines, malaysia and brunei. Island and matsu island conflict between government of laos and north viet nambacked pathet lao forces uprising of the prodalai lama faction over the tibetan problems border dispute conflict between u. A taiwan after ww2 claim the spratly island as early as 1946 after the defeat of japan it established a garrison itu aba spratly island west york islands apparently to forestall french attempt to return to the area but abandoned it in 1950 because of two things 1. The south china sea territorial dispute is a complex issue in international.
Contemporary asian studies series no claim whatsoever over the spratly islands. The spratly islands dispute is an ongoing territorial dispute between china, taiwan, malaysia, the philippines, vietnam, and brunei, concerning ownership of the spratly islands, a group of islands and associated maritime features reefs, banks, cays, etc. As a vietnamese, i am rather certain that vietnam government. China added missile systems on spratly islands in south china sea. The dispute is characterised by diplomatic stalemate and the employment of military pressure techniques. China strategic competition in south and east china seas. International law, conflicting claims, and alternative frameworks for dispute resolution.
Spratly islands, group of about 100 low islands and coral reefs in the central south china sea, intersecting busy shipping lanes. It is further complicated by historical claims that do not jibe well with modern international law. Philippines all permanently occupy features in the spratly group. Chinese involvement in the spratly island dispute in the south china sea. I have gathered facts that support the claims of the philippines over the spratly islands and the scarborough shoal. The dispute is characterised by diplomatic stalemate and the employment of military pressure techniques such as military occupation of disputed territory in the advancement of national territorial claims. The paper highlights the evolution of the dispute and current developments within the south china sea. International law and the dispute over the spratly islands. Small wonder that neighbouring countries claim territorial ownership. Introduction one of the most contending, more disturbing and. In 1991 chinas xinhua news agency beijing published reference material with a partial definition.
These island disputes clearly illustrate the puzzling pattern of continuity and mutual restraint in east asias territorial conflicts. What role for normalizing relations between china and taiwan, 32 new eng. Declaration on the spratlys and south china sea, may 10, 1995. The area includes more than 200 small islands, rocks, and reefs, with the majority located in the paracel and spratly island chains. Territorial dispute, neoliberal institutionalism, south china sea i. The archipelago lies off the coasts of the philippines and malaysia sabah, about one third of the way from there to southern vietnam. The findings revealed that the six countries advance their claims over the spratly islands on the bases of sovereignty and maritime jurisdiction, economic and strategic interests. The spratly islands are a disputed group of more than 750 reefs, islands, cays, atolls, and islets in the south china sea that are critical to nations in the region for strategic and economic reasons. Spratly rocks dispute a rockapelago defies norms of. Malaysia and the philippines have contended that they do not claim the spratly islands because they do not claim spratly island, itself see below. The claim of china at first it was nationalist china a. Gendreau in her work, sovereignty over the paracel and spratly islands.
The dispute of the spratly island features is a longstanding issue among the six littoral coastal parties china, taiwan, vietnam, the philippines, malaysia and brunei around the south china sea. Index introductionspratly island controversy 1 physical features of the spratly islands 1 petroleum and natural gas reserves 1 commercial fishing 2 commercial shipping 2 tourism industry 3. Map of territorial claims in the spratly islands circa 2012. Since then, the island became res nullius and available for occupation. The currently most contentious territorial dispute concerns the spratly archipelago. Chinas new military installations in the spratly islands. The area includes coral reefs, rock formations, islets, cays, atolls and 18 small islands. This marine environment, including more than 750 reefs, islets, atolls, cays, and islands, has a rich ecosystems, but is mired in a tugofwar between several nations. Frances annexation of six of the spratly islands that month. Later in 1956, tomas cloma, a filipino, independently declared a state on the islands, calling them freedomland.
Why spratly islands is important to china, and philippines. Why does the united states care about what happens to the. Pdf the modern origins of chinas south china sea claims. Oct 11, 2014 for the spratly island dispute, the u. Territorial disputes in the south china sea wikipedia. Malaysia was formed on 16 september 1963 in the merger of the federation of malaya with the former british colonies of north borneo, sarawak and singapore. The islands were sporadically visited throughout the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries by mariners from different european powers including either richard or william spratly, after whom the island group derives. February fiery cross reef foreign minister gulf of tonkin hallertrost hanoi heinzig historic waters indonesia international law island groups jakarta japan jiao june kalayaan malaysia march mischief reef natuna islands north vietnam november occupied october offshore oil exploration paracel and. A dispute between china and south vietnam over the ownership of two archipelagos in the south china sea, the paracel islands and the spratly or spratley islands, led to a naval battle.
The hague has delivered a political handgrenade with its surprisingly harsh and clear decision in the case of the philippines vs. Territorial dispute of the spratly islands in the south. Pdf this article offers a new account of the development of chinas territorial claims in the south china. The spratly islands dispute is a regional maritime territorial sovereignty dispute which involves six countries in the south china sea china, taiwan, vietnam, philippines, malaysia and brunei. Pdf disputes and overlapping claims over spratly islands. Spratly island, like most of the other islands and cays in the group, sits on a larger coral bank or atoll. Territorial disputes in the south china sea involve both island and maritime claims among seven sovereign states within the region, namely brunei, the peoples republic of china, taiwan, malaysia, the philippines, and vietnam.
The spratly islands are located in the central region of the south china sea. Introduction the spratly island the spratly islands are a group of more than 750 reefs,2 islets, atolls, cays and islands in the south china sea. Out of its economic and security motives, malaysia entered the spratly islands dispute, making it more complex. The spratly islands dispute can be looked at from a variety of angles. China, taiwan, and the philippines are not the only claimants to the spratly islands. The spratly islands dispute prc claim on spratly islands viewed the government of malaysia has issued an important statement as a reaction to the recent claim by the peoples republic of china concerning the spratly islands. Western definition regarding freedom of the seas, and.